I had been working the case for weeks. A random murder in a suburb. We had made no progress, no murder weapon, no suspect. Our investigation team had only found the body by chance. I was on the verge of madness, the district attorney was breathing down my neck. Apparently the woman's father was a golfing buddy of his and they wanted results. It should seem obvious the choice I then made.
I made him up.
Honestly I did. There was no murderer, and there was nearly no evidence. What was I to do?
So I invented him.
A middle aged man, medium build, with grey hair, and wearing a suit.
I typed up a fictitious transcript of an interview with a local drifter who had also been found dead. I had something to show the DA, and I thought that it would disappear.
But I was wrong.
The anguished father found out of course, and he plastered wanted posters with the description of my fake suspect for miles around. A sketch was on a billboard, news anchors were discussing him. Everyone was talking about the man in the suit.
I had made a living hell for myself.
I was forced to answer questions, and invent more lies. I gave interview after interview about this man who didn’t exist.
He may have a scar on his left cheek, he could be driving a black sedan, his preferred weapon was a Glock 17 fitted with a suppressor due to the lack of reported gunshots.
I hear you disagreeing, but you must understand that he was never real.
At least that’s what I keep telling myself.
Then the sightings came.
The 22nd of November, six weeks after the murder, he was spotted on a security camera buying gas not two miles from the suspected scene of the crime.
Of course I didn’t follow up the leads, I had invented this man after all.
But the next day there was another sighting.
Then another.
And another.
I finally had to act, and instructed my fellow police officers to be on the lookout and to bring him in if spotted.
None of them did.
But the reports kept coming in.
Outside the dead womans house, near the church she visited, at the entrance to the city morgue.
It was impossible. I was receiving reports of the figure across town at exactly the same time.
After a week I was called in to the DAs office.
He wanted to know why I hadn’t caught this man. Why he was still out on the streets making a mockery of his town and its police force.
I had no answers for him of course.
Then he told me to go out there personally. He sat there, in his leather high backed chair and told me that I was forbidden to return to my office until I had apprehended the suspect.
What was I to do? How could I handcuff someone who I invented?
I went home and pondered just ending it all with a gun in my mouth.
But then I looked outside, and there he was. Standing underneath the streetlamp, right next to his black sedan, staring back at me.
I froze.
It was impossible. How could he be here, looking back at me with those blue eyes. Or were they grey? My fictional account wasn’t sure, and right now I couldn’t be either. He seemed to be almost a painting, or illustration given manifest form.
He shimmered, and seemed to constantly change as though out of focus or viewed through frosted glass.
I backed away from the window and put my .38 revolver in my coat pocket, then stepped out the front door.
The closer I approached him, the darker the surrounding lights became, until even the streetlamp seemed to be just a flickering memory. A greyish haze more than a light.
He was just as I had described him. Tall, gaunt, with a scar on his cheek and a slightly unshaven face.
“Who are you?”
I asked.
He smiled.
“You know exactly who I am.”
He said.
“You made me. You gave me life, purpose, and a face. Faith is a powerful thing detective. You trumpeted my existence to a town of half a million, and they all wanted to see me. They all wanted me to appear. And lo, I did. Here I am detective. Am I everything you wanted?”
I was quaking. Days without sleep had brought about his hallucination, I was certain of it. But I had one way to prove it.
I plunged my hand into my coat pocket, and fired all six shots into his tall figure.
The bullets passed through, leaving his clothing unmarked, but they all impacted the brick wall across the street.
He smiled.
“I’m more than a man now detective. I am a shared belief. And those are much, much more difficult to kill. Not even the truth can bring me down now.”
I watched helplessly as he pulled a suppressed Glock from his coat, and shot me twice in the chest. As I fell to the pavement he grabbed me by my shirt, and holding me close to him whispered into my ear.
“Thank you.”
He dropped me like a wet sandbag onto the sidewalk, strode to his car, and drove off.
I know you think me mad. You think all of this stress has gotten to my head, but I tell you it is the truth. He is not real. I swear it! He is not real!
I typed up a fictitious transcript of an interview with a local drifter who had also been found dead. I had something to show the DA, and I thought that it would disappear.
But I was wrong.
The anguished father found out of course, and he plastered wanted posters with the description of my fake suspect for miles around. A sketch was on a billboard, news anchors were discussing him. Everyone was talking about the man in the suit.
I had made a living hell for myself.
I was forced to answer questions, and invent more lies. I gave interview after interview about this man who didn’t exist.
He may have a scar on his left cheek, he could be driving a black sedan, his preferred weapon was a Glock 17 fitted with a suppressor due to the lack of reported gunshots.
I hear you disagreeing, but you must understand that he was never real.
At least that’s what I keep telling myself.
Then the sightings came.
The 22nd of November, six weeks after the murder, he was spotted on a security camera buying gas not two miles from the suspected scene of the crime.
Of course I didn’t follow up the leads, I had invented this man after all.
But the next day there was another sighting.
Then another.
And another.
I finally had to act, and instructed my fellow police officers to be on the lookout and to bring him in if spotted.
None of them did.
But the reports kept coming in.
Outside the dead womans house, near the church she visited, at the entrance to the city morgue.
It was impossible. I was receiving reports of the figure across town at exactly the same time.
After a week I was called in to the DAs office.
He wanted to know why I hadn’t caught this man. Why he was still out on the streets making a mockery of his town and its police force.
I had no answers for him of course.
Then he told me to go out there personally. He sat there, in his leather high backed chair and told me that I was forbidden to return to my office until I had apprehended the suspect.
What was I to do? How could I handcuff someone who I invented?
I went home and pondered just ending it all with a gun in my mouth.
But then I looked outside, and there he was. Standing underneath the streetlamp, right next to his black sedan, staring back at me.
I froze.
It was impossible. How could he be here, looking back at me with those blue eyes. Or were they grey? My fictional account wasn’t sure, and right now I couldn’t be either. He seemed to be almost a painting, or illustration given manifest form.
He shimmered, and seemed to constantly change as though out of focus or viewed through frosted glass.
I backed away from the window and put my .38 revolver in my coat pocket, then stepped out the front door.
The closer I approached him, the darker the surrounding lights became, until even the streetlamp seemed to be just a flickering memory. A greyish haze more than a light.
He was just as I had described him. Tall, gaunt, with a scar on his cheek and a slightly unshaven face.
“Who are you?”
I asked.
He smiled.
“You know exactly who I am.”
He said.
“You made me. You gave me life, purpose, and a face. Faith is a powerful thing detective. You trumpeted my existence to a town of half a million, and they all wanted to see me. They all wanted me to appear. And lo, I did. Here I am detective. Am I everything you wanted?”
I was quaking. Days without sleep had brought about his hallucination, I was certain of it. But I had one way to prove it.
I plunged my hand into my coat pocket, and fired all six shots into his tall figure.
The bullets passed through, leaving his clothing unmarked, but they all impacted the brick wall across the street.
He smiled.
“I’m more than a man now detective. I am a shared belief. And those are much, much more difficult to kill. Not even the truth can bring me down now.”
I watched helplessly as he pulled a suppressed Glock from his coat, and shot me twice in the chest. As I fell to the pavement he grabbed me by my shirt, and holding me close to him whispered into my ear.
“Thank you.”
He dropped me like a wet sandbag onto the sidewalk, strode to his car, and drove off.
I know you think me mad. You think all of this stress has gotten to my head, but I tell you it is the truth. He is not real. I swear it! He is not real!
